Da ich in mein Fritz Test turnier einige differenzen gemerkt habe zwischen Atlanta und Magellan, habe ich ein paar Klon Test spiele mit diese beiden gemacht:

Test 1

Ich habe die weissen zuege forciert. Atlanta spielt schwarz.

Nach 11. Rc1 spielt Atlanta seine eigene zuege. Da das originale spiel gespielt war mit Selective on and Random off, in diesen Test spielt Atlanta mit der gleichen einstellung. Das spiel ist das Spiel 2 von der Atlanta - Magellan begegnung in Fritz Test Turnier:

Spiel 2 von Atlanta-Magellan begegnung. Atlanta spielt diesmal schwarz

1. d4 d5 2. c4 e6 3. Nc3 c5 4. cxd5 exd5 5. Nf3 Nc6 6. g3 Nf6 7. Bg2 Be7 8. O-O Be6 9. dxc5 Bxc5 10. Bg5 O-O 11. Rc1 {out of book} Be7 12. Qa4 a6 13. Rfd1 b5 14. Qf4 Rc8 15. Rc2 Qa5 16. a3 b4 17. axb4 Nxb4 18. Rcc1 Nc6 19. Nd4 Nxd4 20. Qxd4 Bc5

(20... Rc4 {Atlanta Variation 1})

21. Qf4 Ng4

(21... Be7 {Atlanta variation 2})

22. e3 Rb8 23. Ra1 Qb4 24. Nxd5 Qxb2 25. Be7 Bxd5 26. Bxc5 Nxf2 27. Qxf2 Qxf2+ 28. Kxf2 Rb2+ 29. Ke1 Rxg2 30. Bxf8 Kxf8 31. Rxa6 Bc4 32. Ra8+ Ke7 33. Rd2 Rxd2 34. Kxd2 Bd5 35. Ra7+ Ke6 36. Kd3 Ke5 37. Ra5 Ke6

(37... f5 {Atlanta variation 3})

38. Kd4 Bc6 39. e4 h6 40. h4 Kd6 41. e5+ Ke7

(41... Kc7 {Atlanta variation 4})

42. Ra7+ Ke6 43. Ra6 Kd7 44. Kc5 Bb7 45. Ra7 Kc7 46. h5 Kc8 47. Kd6 Kb8 48. Rxb7+ Kxb7 49. Ke7 g6 50. Kxf7 gxh5 51. e6 Kc6

(51... Kb6 {Atlanta variation 5})

52. e7 Kd5

(52... Kc5 {Atlanta variation 6})

53. e8=Q Kd4 54. Kf6 Kd3 55. Qxh5 Kd4 56. Qxh6 Kd5 57. g4 Ke4 58. g5 Kd4 59. g6 Kd5 60. g7 Kc5 61. g8=Q Kd6

(61... Kb4 {Atlanta variation 7})

62. Qhf8+ Kc6 63. Qc4+ Kb6 64. Qd6+ Ka5 65. Qdb4# 1-0

Total unforced moves: 53
Total move variance: 7
% clone probability: 86.79%

Test 2 Brute Force Test

In diesen Test spielen beide Magellan und Atlanta gegen Rybka mit Brute Force.

[Event "Clone Test - Atlanta/Magellan"]
[Site "Brute Force 30sec/move"]
[Date "2007.12.22"]
[White "Mephisto Atlanta/Magellan"]
[Black "Rybka 2.1c 32bit"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C69"]
[Annotator "Mind,Spacious"]
[PlyCount "126"]

{Brute Force test Atlanta & Magellan against Rybka 2.1c 32bit} 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Bxc6 dxc6 5. O-O f6 6. d4 Bg4 7. dxe5 Qxd1 8. Rxd1 fxe5 9. Nc3 Nf6 10. Rd3 Bxf3 11. gxf3 Bd6 12. Be3

{Last forced move}

O-O-O 13. a3 {Mephisto Atlanta moved first by approx 10 secs} Be7 14. Rxd8+ Rxd8 15. f4 exf4 16. Bxf4 g5 17. Bxg5 Rg8 18. f4 h6 19. h4 hxg5 20. hxg5 Nh5 {Magellan taking a minute longer to move} 21. Ne2 Bd6 22. Rf1 Re8 23. e5 Nxf4 24. Nxf4 Rxe5 25. Nh3 Re3 26. Nf4 Rg3+ 27. Ng2 Rxg5 28. Kf2 Rb5 29. b4 a5 30. c3 Rf5+ 31. Ke2 Rxf1 32. Kxf1 Be5 33. c4

(33. Ne3 {Var 1 Magellan move (not a ponder move)})

33... Bb2 34. bxa5 Bxa3 35. Ke2 Bb4 36. Kd3 Kd7 37. Kd4 c5+ 38. Ke4

(38. Ke3 {Var 2 Magellan move (not a ponder move)})

38... c6 39. a6 bxa6 40. Nf4 Bc3 41. Ne2 Bf6 42. Kf5 Ke7 43. Nc1 a5 44. Nb3 a4 45. Nxc5 a3 46. Nb3 a2 47. Ke4 a1=Q 48. Nxa1 Bxa1 49. Kf5 Kd6 50. Ke4

(50. Kf4 {Var 3 Magellan move})

50... Bf6 51. Kf5 Kc5 52. Ke6 Kxc4 53. Kd6 c5 54. Kc6 Be5 55. Kb6 Kd5 56. Kb5

(56. Ka5 {Var 4 Magellan move})

56... Bd6 57. Ka5 c4 58. Ka4

(58. Kb6 {Var 5 Magellan move})

58... Kc6 59. Ka5 c3 60. Ka4 c2 61. Kb3 c1=Q 62. Ka2 Qc2+ 63. Ka1 Be5# 0-1

Total unforced moves: 50
Total move variance: 5
% clone probability: 90%

In the next test I set both Magellan and Atlanta up with Selective and forced them to repeat the Brute Force game that they had just played and here is the result:

Test 3 Selective Test

In diesen Test wiederholen beide das Test 2 spiel aber dieses mal mit Selective einstellung.

[Event "Clone Test - Atlanta/Magellan"]
[Site "Selective 30sec/move"]
[Date "2007.12.22"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Mephisto Atlanta/Magellan"]
[Black "Rybka 2.1c 32bit"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C69"]
[Annotator "Mind,Spacious"]
[PlyCount "126"]

{Selective test Atlanta & Magellan against Rybka 2.1c 32bit} 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Bxc6 dxc6 5. O-O f6 6. d4 Bg4 7. dxe5 Qxd1 8. Rxd1 fxe5 9. Nc3 Nf6 10. Rd3 Bxf3 11. gxf3 Bd6 12. Be3

{Last forced move}

O-O-O 13. a3 Be7 14. Rxd8+ Rxd8 15. f4 exf4 16. Bxf4 g5 17. Bxg5 Rg8 18. f4 h6 19. h4 hxg5 20. hxg5

(20. fxg5 {Var 1 Atlanta})

20... Nh5 21. Ne2

(21. Rf1 {Var 2 Atlanta})

21... Bd6 22. Rf1 Re8 23. e5 Nxf4 24. Nxf4 Rxe5 25. Nh3

(25. g6 {Var 3 Atlanta})

25... Re3 26. Nf4

(26. Nf2 {Var 4 Atlanta})

26... Rg3+ 27. Ng2 Rxg5 28. Kf2 Rb5 29. b4 a5 30. c3 Rf5+ 31. Ke2 Rxf1 32. Kxf1 Be5 33. c4 Bb2 34. bxa5 Bxa3 35. Ke2 Bb4 36. Kd3

(36. Nf4 {Var 4 Atlanta})

36... Kd7 37. Kd4 c5+ 38. Ke4

(38. Ke5 {Var 1 Magellan})

38... c6 39. a6

(39. Nf4 {Var 5 Atlanta})

39... bxa6 40. Nf4

(40. Kf5 {Var 2 Magellan})

40... Bc3 41. Ne2

(41. Kf5 {Var 3 Magellan})

41... Bf6 42. Kf5

(42. Nc1 {Var 6 Atlanta})

42... Ke7 43. Nc1 a5 44. Nb3 a4 45. Nxc5 a3 46. Nb3 a2 47. Ke4

(47. Kf4 {Var 7 Atlanta})

47... a1=Q 48. Nxa1 Bxa1 49. Kf5 Kd6 50. Ke4

(50. Kf4 {Var 4 Magellan})

50... Bf6 51. Kf5 Kc5 52. Ke6 Kxc4 53. Kd6 c5 54. Kc6 Be5 55. Kb6 Kd5 56. Kb5

(56. Ka5 {Var 5 Magellan})

56... Bd6 57. Ka5 c4 58. Ka4

(58. Kb6 {Var 6 Magellan})

58... Kc6 59. Ka5 c3 60. Ka4 c2 61. Kb3 c1=Q 62. Ka2 Qc2+ 63. Ka1 Be5# 0-1

Thirteen different unique moves were played between the two of them in Selective mode!

Total unforced moves: 50
Total move variance: 13
% clone probability: 74%

Ich bin ueberzeugt das mein Atlanta und Magellan NICHT genaue Klons sind.

Was meint Ihr? Koennt Ihr auch bitte eure testen.

Gruss

Nick